Best Substitutes for Cows Milk

Taking Out Dairy-Pasteurized cow’s milk is considered the top allergen and many children’s symptoms improve greatly when it is taken out.  Hyperactivity, impulsivity, aggression, perpetually stuffy nose, exhaustion, headaches, bed wetting, and eczema are  some of the issues I have seen resolve when dairy is removed.

Removing dairy can be problematic for some families… perhaps your child adores it (craves it, even); perhaps you use it to enhance the taste of other foods they won’t otherwise eat; perhaps your child uses a cup or bottle of milk for comfort at bedtime. Perhaps you rely on it as a go-to snack.

Parents generally express two concerns to me when advised to remove dairy: What to replace it with as a beverage, and what to do about calcium.  I want to address both those issues, as well as a few others, and offer you suggestions for milk substitutions.

Milk is a convenient food as it is one of the few that combines fats, carbohydrates and protein all in one package.  It is also a good source of calcium and is typically fortified with vitamin D and sometimes vitamin A – two important vitamins that can be difficult to get into your child.  So, when I suggest a parent remove diary, we look at 3 factors: 

  1. how to find other sources of protein and other snacks that combine all macronutrients;
  2. how to find another source for calcium and vitamin D; and
  3. how to replace the comfort milk sometimes brings as a beverage (if applicable)

Here are some alternatives to cow’s milk.

Animal Milks:

If you’re looking for a nutritional equivalent, try milk from another animal.  Milk from sheep, camel, goat, and buffalo are sometimes better tolerated than milk from cows because the proteins are slightly different and these milks are generally not homogenized.  You’ll see in the chart at the bottom of this post that they match up nicely with cow’s milk in terms of nutrients.

Non-Dairy Milks:

If the alternative animal milks are not available, not well liked or not well tolerated, you can turn to the nut and seed milks.   Almond, coconut, hemp and flax milks are readily available and are also easy to make yourself. 

Keep in mind that these non-dairy milks are not at all the same as animal milks in terms of nutritional profile (refer to the chart below).  While they are typically fortified with vitamins and minerals they are not good sources of carbohydrate or protein.  They are also higher in omega 6 fatty acids (with the exception of coconut), which can exacerbate inflammatory conditions.  They also often contain unwanted additives. 

I suggest these milks be used only occasionally in cooking or as weening tools to get children out of the habit of using milk for comfort.  I don’t consider them to be healthy foods, per say.  (Note: Coconut cream would be the exception here as it provides a great dietary fat for kids – though it’s not really a “drink” so wouldn’t be used in the same way as the nut/see milks I’m referring to here).

Milks to avoid:

There are 2 non-dairy milks that I do not recommend.  They are rice and soy. 

I no longer recommend rice milk because rice has been found to contain high levels of inorganic arsenic that can cause health problems.  As for soy, I no longer recommend it because of concerns over the estrogenic effects of soy, particularly its possible adverse effects on the thyroid.

Additives to look out for:

Most nut and seed milks have a lot of additives in them so you have to read the labels carefully.  Here’s what to look for:

  1. Guar gum.  I’m not very concerned about this additive if consumed in moderation, but do be aware that for some people it can trigger diarrhea
  2. Carrageenan.  This additive, derived from algae, has stirred a bit of controversy.  A few studies have shown it has the potential to cause inflammation and increased permeability in the gut, other studies do not support this.  Here’s a nice synopsis.  More study on this one is needed, but until then I suggest avoiding it as much as possible if you are dealing with digestive issues and allergy due to the potential adverse effects.
  3. Many brands are fortified with calcium carbonate.  Again, I do not find this usually to be a problem, but be aware that in some people it can cause constipation by lowering stomach acid levels.

Making your own non-dairy milks:

It’s quite simple to make your own nut/seed milks and this is the only way to keep the additives out.  Visit my youtube channel for directions. 

The basic formula is to blend a ratio of 1 part nut/seed to 2 parts filtered water for a few minutes and then strain out the pulp through a jelly bag (coconut, hemp and almonds need to be pre soaked before blending).  You can sweeten by adding a date or two or a bit of honey;  you can add your own vitamin fortification using supplements if you feel your child isn’t getting those elsewhere.

So… What’s a mama to do?

If you suspect a dairy intolerance, the first thing to try is fermented cow’s milk in the form of a good quality plain yogurt or kefir.  Look for one that has only whole milk and bacteria listed as the ingredients – no sweeteners, thickeners or other additives. When dairy is fermented, the problematic proteins and sugars are broken down and enzymes are created so the food becomes more digestible.  Many children who do not tolerate milk do fine with a good quality yogurt or kefir.

If your child does not tolerate fermented cow’s dairy, try one of the other animal milks listed above.  Yogurt made with these milks is also widely available.

If those are still not tolerated, try one of the nut/seed milks.  Think of them, though, as an occasional beverage or a weaning tool, rather than as a nutritious food. 

What I recommend most commonly is a combination of almond milk (if nuts are tolerated) and coconut cream. Almonds are higher in natural calcium than some of the others (though still much less than cow’s milk) and adding 1 tblsp coconut oil or coconut cream will increase the healthy fat content which is critical for your child’s immune and brain health.  This combo is still not a good source of protein or calcium, however.  You’ll have to get that from other foods or supplements.

If you are making your own nut/seed milk (which I recommend doing if possible so you keep the additives out), I recommend a good cod liver oil for vitamins A and D and potentially a calcium supplement if you are not able to get other calcium rich foods like almonds, sesame seeds, broccoli and spinach into your child.

The Bottom line…

Nut or seed milk alternatives can not be considered “equivalent” nutrition-wise to cow’s milk.  In particular they lack fat and protein.  However, they  can make for a nice beverage if you are weaning a child off of cow’s milk or need something for cooking or baking.  Making your own is best, and you can use good quality supplements if you feel your child isn’t getting enough from other foods.

The animal milks more closely resemble cow’s milk in terms of nutrients.  They are often better tolerated because the proteins are a little different than those found in cow’s milk, but not always.  They also can sometimes have a distinct flavour that some children might not like.

Nutritional profile of some milks (for 1 cup of each):

Cow’s milk: fat 8g; carb 13g; protein 8g; calcium 28%

Camel milk: fat 5g; carb 12g; protein 8g; calcium 32%

Sheep milk: fat 17g; carb 13g; protein 15g; calcium 47%

Goat milk: fat 10g; carb 11g; protein 9g; calcium 33%

Buffalo milk: fat 17g; carb 13g; protein 9g; calcium 41%

Unsweetened Flax milk: fat 2.5g; carb 1g; protein 0g; calcium 30%

Unsweetened Almond milk: fat 3g; carb 2g; protein 1g; calcium 20%

Unsweetened Hemp milk: fat 5g; carb 1g; protein 2g; calcium 25%

Rice milk: fat 2.5g; carb 11g; protein 0g; calcium 25%

Full fat Coconut milk (1 tblsp): fat 3.6g; carb 1g; protein 0.5g; calcium 0%

Learn more about how to safely try a dairy free diet here.


 

2 Comments

  • Magda

    Reply Reply February 27, 2016

    Great article! Do you have any clients who have successfully weaned their kids off milk, and if so, was it a struggle?

    • Jess Sherman

      Reply Reply March 1, 2016

      thanks Magda! Yes I have, and yes, it can be. Depends if the child is addicted to it. It can be a slow process. But for some it’s more a comfort thing and in that case it is easier to provide substitutes.

Leave A Response

* Denotes Required Field